Building Your Security Stack: An Interview with Richard Stiennon
FOURCAST
The advantages of platforms vs. best-of-breed as cybersecurity evolves
Published: 2025
FOURCAST
The advantages of platforms vs. best-of-breed as cybersecurity evolves
Published: 2025
Security leaders continuously evaluate how to balance integration and flexibility in their security stack. Their choices are shaped by risk, operational complexity, and long-term strategy.
FOURCASTERS sat down with Richard Stiennon, a cybersecurity industry analyst with more than 30 years of industry experience, to discuss how organizations navigate these decisions. Alongside his work as a leading industry analyst, Stiennon produces an extensive ranking and rating of over 11,000 products across more than 4,000 vendors, giving him a broad view of the cybersecurity landscape.
Many vendors promote the benefits of comprehensive security platforms—claiming seamless integration, fewer tools to manage, and a single-pane-of-glass approach. Platforms can reduce complexity, streamline operations, and provide consistent policy enforcement across security functions.
Stiennon understands the appeal: “It sounds good, right? The idea that all security functions touching the same domain should be unified in one platform, so you don’t have to juggle multiple dashboards,” he says.
However, Stiennon contends that simplicity should not be sought at the expense of efficacy. Security needs are constantly evolving. Attackers shift tactics, new vulnerabilities emerge, and businesses must adapt quickly. Stiennon emphasis that a best-of-breed approach allows security teams to select specialized tools that provide the best fit for their needs and organization.
“It is my contention that CISOs should not have a KPI for fewer vendors or fewer tools,” Stiennon says. “That’s not the goal. Every cybersecurity tool serves a purpose. It was purchased to serve a specific function.”
.
Stiennon states that, where there is commonality amongst teams and domains—such as network security—consolidation can make sense. “On the network, you should have a platform. You don’t need separate appliances for secure web gateway functions, content filtering, firewalling, and intrusion prevention. That should all be one. And the same goes for the endpoint,” he says. However, he notes that expecting a single platform to be the best at everything presents challenges, and teams would still need specialists managing different aspects of security.
Stiennon also isn’t convinced that a one-platform-for-all approach always benefits vendors either. He understands why large vendors may focus on expanding sales through upselling existing customers over seeking new ones. “The financial bond is already there with their current client base, the doors are open, and the trust is built,” he explains. Yet, Stiennon points to major vendors that made hundreds of acquisitions only to become unmanageable, leading to its eventual breakup and sale.
Stiennon advises organizations to evaluate security tools based on effectiveness, first and foremost. Reducing the number of vendors an organization works with doesn’t necessarily simplify security operations or improve outcomes.
Ultimately, organizations must balance operational efficiency, risk management, and adaptability to emerging threats.
“The right tools, addressing the right problems and properly integrated, will always be the winning combination” Stiennon concludes.

Roberta Gamble is the Chief Research Analyst at FOURCASTERS, a future-focused content hub for independent analysts and firms. With over 25 years of experience in industry research, Gamble specializes in how technology transforms businesses, particularly in contact centers, unified communications, and AI.